Where to Celebrate Thanksgiving in Marathon, Florida: Top Dining Spots and Holiday Events

As Thanksgiving approaches, Marathon, Florida, offers locals and visitors a range of options to make the holiday special. Whether you're searching for a traditional Thanksgiving dinner, a unique island twist on the feast, or a cozy spot to dine, this guide will help you find the best places to enjoy the November holiday.

Thanksgiving Dinner in Marathon Florida

If you're spending Thanksgiving in the heart of the Florida Keys, you're in for a treat! Many restaurants in Marathon put on special Thanksgiving dinners, offering delicious meals with stunning ocean views and tropical vibes. Here are some top spots to consider:

1. The Island Fish Company

Located right on the water, The Island Fish Company is known for its fresh seafood and stunning sunsets. For Thanksgiving, they typically offer a traditional turkey dinner with all the fixings, along with some seafood options for those looking to mix it up. Prices usually range from $30 to $45 per person, depending on the meal package, and reservations are highly recommended due to the holiday rush.

• Price Range: $30-$45 per person
• Reservations: Yes, call ahead to book a table early.

1. Key Colony Inn

A local favorite, Key Colony Inn serves a special Thanksgiving menu that features traditional turkey dinners with mashed potatoes, stuffing, and cranberry sauce. Known for its generous portions and family-friendly atmosphere, the meals are reasonably priced at around $25-$35 per person. This spot is perfect for those looking for a home-style holiday meal. Reservations are highly recommended, especially for larger groups.

• Price Range: $25-$35 per person
• Reservations: Yes, especially for groups.

1. Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club

For a waterfront Thanksgiving experience, Faro Blanco offers both indoor and outdoor dining options. Their holiday menu typically includes Thanksgiving staples like roasted turkey and pumpkin pie, as well as fresh seafood dishes. Meals are priced around $45 per person, and the atmosphere is ideal for a more upscale celebration. Reservations are required due to limited seating by the marina.

• Price Range: $45 per person
• Reservations: Yes, required.

1. Sparky’s Landing

Situated in Key Colony FL, Sparky’s Landing is a casual, fun spot for a Thanksgiving dinner. Alongside their regular menu, which features fresh seafood and tropical drinks, they often offer a special Thanksgiving meal for around $25-$30 per person. The lively atmosphere and waterfront views make it a great choice for those seeking a relaxed holiday meal. Reservations are encouraged but not always required.

• Price Range: $25-$30 per person
• Reservations: Recommended, but walk-ins are welcome if space allows.

1. Florida Keys Steak and Lobster House

This upscale, Marathon Florida restaurant, offers a Thanksgiving special featuring traditional meals like roast turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, and cranberry sauce, alongside their famous steak and lobster dishes. Prices for Thanksgiving meals range from $40-$50 per person, and reservations are strongly recommended to secure a table.

• Price Range: $40-$50 per person
• Reservations: Yes, strongly recommended.

1. Brutus Seafood

For a casual, laid-back Thanksgiving, Brutus Seafood offers a more relaxed vibe with fresh local seafood options as well as Thanksgiving favorites. The price for a Thanksgiving meal ranges between $20 and $30 per person. No formal reservations are required, but it’s good to call ahead and check availability if you're planning to visit during peak hours.

• Price Range: $20-$30 per person
• Reservations: Not required, but calling ahead is advised.

1. Butterfly Café at Tranquility Bay Resort

For an elegant Thanksgiving experience, Butterfly Café offers a prix fixe menu featuring both traditional Thanksgiving dishes and gourmet tropical-inspired cuisine. Meals are priced around $60 per person, and this is one of the more upscale options for Thanksgiving dining in Marathon. Reservations are essential due to the limited seating.

• Price Range: $60 per person
• Reservations: Required, call in advance.

Private Chefs in Marathon

For those looking to have a more intimate and personalized Thanksgiving meal, several local chefs in Marathon offer private dining experiences. Whether you’re staying in a vacation rental or your own home, private chefs can prepare a custom Thanksgiving feast, allowing you to relax and enjoy the holiday without worrying about cooking.

• Key Providers: Some recommended private chef services include A Family Affair and Florida Keys Private Chefs. Pricing typically ranges from $75-$150 per person, depending on the menu and group size, with options for both traditional and seafood-inspired meals.
• Reservations: Private chef services book up quickly for holidays, so it’s best to arrange your meal weeks in advance.

November Holiday Meals in Marathon

Beyond Thanksgiving Day, many Marathon restaurants feature special holiday menus throughout November, so you can get into the holiday spirit all month long. Several local spots may offer early Thanksgiving buffets or even take-out options, perfect for those who want to enjoy a meal in the comfort of their Marathon vacation rental or home.

Check out local favorites like Castaway Waterfront Restaurant & Sushi Bar for unique holiday meal options, or Lazy Days South for casual, delicious bites in a waterfront setting.

Thanksgiving Events in Marathon

In addition to delicious meals, Marathon also offers events and activities to enjoy over the Thanksgiving holiday:

The Annual Turkey Trot 5K: Kick off your Thanksgiving morning by joining the community for the annual 5K run/walk. It’s a fun way to get active before indulging in your holiday meal, and it’s a family-friendly event for all ages.

• Holiday Boat Parade (Early December): While not directly on Thanksgiving, the festive Marathon Lighted Boat Parade is a highly anticipated event that kicks off the holiday season in early December. If you’re staying past Thanksgiving weekend, this is an event you won’t want to miss.

Make Reservations Early

Thanksgiving is a popular time in Marathon, with visitors flocking to enjoy the beautiful weather and local attractions. To ensure you have a spot at your preferred restaurant or secure a private chef, it’s wise to make reservations well in advance. Many restaurants also offer takeout options if you'd prefer to have your Thanksgiving feast in a more intimate setting.

After your meal perhaps you would like to have one of Coco Plum Real Estate advisors help you with your purchase or Marathon Florida Real Estate.